Lock SJ1 won

[Hungry Panda]

The Rules are pretty basic.

 

Any Effect type monster.

Winner gets 3 reps loser gets 1.

first one to comment is my challenger.

good luck to you all.

 

Here's my card:

[Yang Xiao-Long]

I'll go. No ninjas.

 

What are the rules?

[Hungry Panda]

I'll go. No ninjas.

 

What are the rules?

 

Any Effect Monster.

My Card is posted above.

Post your card when it is completed.

[Yang Xiao-Long]

Here's my card.

 

Lore:

This card can and must attack all monsters on your opponent's field once each. During battle between this card and a Defense Position monster whose DEF is lower than the ATK of this card, inflict the difference as Battle Damage to your opponent's Life Points. When this card is removed from the field, destroy all other monsters on your field.

[Hungry Panda]

First to 5 takes the Victory.

 

0-0. it anyones game!

[Yang Xiao-Long]

This means vote people.

[Hungry Panda]

we need votes.

---

Vote Please

---

Vote Please

[Sleepy]

Here's my rubric of d00m for the contest (not really an accurate one btw xD ).

 

Effect:FLIP: Gain 300 Life Points for each Plant-Type monster on the field.

 

-The effect is fairly simple but that's ok. The thing is' date=' its a little slow being a FLIP and a little specific and weak by only making you gain some Life and only counting for Plants.

-On top of it, its a high Level monster, so it needs Tribute. Although neither its effect or its ATK/DEF make up for it.

-The name "Tree of Doom" doesn't quite match with the effect either, being of "doom" but healing your Life.

-I'm not a fan of the pic but its ok.

-Lastly, OCG errors exist there. Although the effect is understandable, the vocabulary there is just different to any yugioh card. On the other hand, speaking of grammar, when you write a type of monster, you say Plant-Type, not "Plant type". and Life Points is another one. Other than those I think its ok.

 

Effect:This card can and must attack all monsters your opponent controls once each. During battle between this attacking card and a Defense Position monster whose DEF is lower than this card's ATK, inflict the difference as Battle Damage to your opponent. When this card is removed from the field, destroy all other monsters you control.

 

-Those changes above aren't really corrections, since I've seen some cards with the writting you put in there, but I like this^ OCG better that's all.

-Card effect is better elaborated and more complex. That is at first sight because its the same as "Ultimate Tyrano" in effect, ATK, Level, except with 1000 Less DEF. I guess Attribute and Type changes make a difference..

-I like this pic, and it goes well with the name.

-Card is not perfect but its overall good. Congrats ;D

 

My vote goes for card 2.

Sorry for the trouble ^-^"

[έκλειψη]

^ THIS.

[Yang Xiao-Long]

2 Votes for me then.

[The Official Jerk of YCM]

my vote goes to the first card =P 1-2

[Hungry Panda]

~SJ1~ i must say your card is probably going to take the victory at this rate.

[Yang Xiao-Long]

We should probably have people give a reason for their votes, otherwise it doesn't count. Votes like this:

 

my vote goes to the first card =P 1-2

 

are not worth the time. They MUST give a reason for their vote. Eclipse's vote still counts because it would have been a repeat of sleepy's otherwise.

[Hungry Panda]

We should probably have people give a reason for their votes' date=' otherwise it doesn't count. Votes like this:

 

my vote goes to the first card =P 1-2

 

are not worth the time. They MUST give a reason for their vote. Eclipse's vote still counts because it would have been a repeat of sleepy's otherwise.

 

I agree

[Yang Xiao-Long]

That didn't mean to stop voting people.

[Yang Xiao-Long]

Vote people.

[Hungry Panda]

Vote now.

[SuperNarb]

My vote goes to SJ1. His card had a more original effect, better picture, and overall better card.

[Rosuke]

Vote for SJ1 , its more Original than the Three , it can Make a lot of damage to your Opponent , and 3000 Attack , it has a cool name and Pic and its Not OP because when is destroyed it destroys all other monster you control , in the other Side Hankaro had a lot of OCG problems in only 15 words...

[Yang Xiao-Long]

4 votes for me then.

[Hungry Panda]

vote people vote

[Hungry Panda]

the last vote for SJ1 will seal the deal guys.

[Hungry Panda]

we need voters.

[Yang Xiao-Long]

Vote people.

[Guest Tainted Black]

Monster's card is really not very useful, it takes 1 tribute for such low use, and there are stronger plants out there that take 1 tribute. Also, Horrbile OCG. It's UP.

 

Now, SJ's card is OP, considering it blows up the field, but it will see more use than Monster's card. I like the must attack drawback for this card, but giving it piercing is a bit much. Still, takes two tributes, and it is better than Monster's

 

My vote is for ~SJ1~