(D) How to accept criticism (Only for grown ups)

[Twenty-five Zero Oh-oh]

Dang it. Why didn't I get on the team? XD lol

[chairman ali]

you couldn't. you don't have anything to pee with' date=' and if you somehow with a miracle would, i would spit it back in ur ugly face, and than pee in ur tiny a******.

[/quote']

 

You're stealing my jokes, n00b.

 

The problem with the criticism on Showcase is' date=' most times it truly is pure flaming.

 

All of you are guilty of this, even myself.

 

And Chaster, you are a legend of hypocrisy.

 

you couldn't. you don't have anything to pee with, and if you somehow with a miracle would, i would spit it back in ur ugly face, and than pee in ur tiny a******.

 

You just accepted someone peeing in your mouth.

>.<

 

If I'm hypocritical I wouldn't post this you idiot. Because I would know then that each and everyone of you will have something against me. SUCK IT UP.

 

Chaster if this behavior continues you will be banned to cool down....

 

If I'm gonna be banned for saying the truth and pointing out that this community fails then let it be.

 

Yin' date=' you gotta admit, it was those guys who were being a******s. And Chaster, it would appear that you, me and Seta/Holmes are the only guys with [s']half[/s] quarter any brain at all. +1 for you and your team, consisting of 3 now.

 

EDIT: Skimming page 2 as well, Kuro, Yondy and Night Walker can get on teh team too.

 

Yin' date=' you gotta admit, it was those guys who were being a******s. And Chaster, it would appear that you, me and Seta/Holmes are the only guys with [s']half[/s] quarter any brain at all. +1 for you and your team, consisting of 3 now.

 

EDIT: Skimming page 2 as well, Kuro, Yondy and Night Walker can get on teh team too.

 

There's n00bs here. Why wouldn't I be here?

 

Yin' date=' you gotta admit, it was those guys who were being a******s. And Chaster, it would appear that you, me and Seta/Holmes are the only guys with [s']half[/s] quarter any brain at all. +1 for you and your team, consisting of 3 now.

 

EDIT: Skimming page 2 as well, Kuro, Yondy and Night Walker can get on teh team too.

 

OH THANKS YOU b****! D:

 

+100000102102454020467806050890 :D

[Seta]

2) I'm not a n00b. I've been here for 3 years and know what a n00b is. I'm NOT saying your a n00b though.

 

So you DON'T know what a noob is =/

 

Shut up and listen to this guys' date=' he's a lot smarter than you.

 

Edit: Oh great, I'm a funking smartass

But seriously, you have no reason to ban Chaster for telling the truth.

 

And also, for all those idiots in this thread, read the title: [b']ONLY for grown ups[/b]

[JG.]

Yin' date=' you gotta admit, it was those guys who were being a******s. And Chaster, it would appear that you, me and Seta/Holmes are the only guys with [s']half[/s] quarter any brain at all. +1 for you and your team, consisting of 3 now.

 

EDIT: Skimming page 2 as well, Kuro, Yondy and Night Walker can get on teh team too. Rain too.

 

OH THANKS YOU b****! D:

 

Sorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorrysorry. Did I say sorry?

[gizmo00999]

For gods sake, I'm not AGAINST this topic, but the flaming seriously isn't the thing to tell some1, otherwise, i completely agree about the criticism

[§hadow §triker]

to 1st post: So true

 

Anyways, this would obviously start arguments. I think this may get me pulled into it...

Chaster- you curse a lot argue with CnC you get too, but you're usually right to argue, i'll give you tht. However you do definitely curse a lot and get in arguments.

Stay mature ppl. Like holes said Only for grown ups Tho that may exclude me considering im 14, lol, but at least im mature. If you're gonna get offended and wanna start an argument here gtfo, cuz everything chaster is saying is true. Got it? Just stay cool.

@Yin- again like holmes, chaster shudnt be banned, but he shud calm down with his cursing.

[Yasu]

It's not about "Telling the truth".

But the way you express it.

So yeah, cool down ^^

[Guest JoshIcy]

ITT: Giving someone criticism means you need to be an twat and an a$$ to get the point across.

 

Since when? If all you are, is mean to the person they will never improve. If all you do is point out the faults they will never learn. If all you do is push them down, they'll never look up.

 

Yeah... Smart.

[chairman ali]

ITT: Giving someone criticism means you need to be an twat and an a$$ to get the point across.

 

Since when? If all you are' date=' is mean to the person they will never improve. [b']If all you do is point out the faults they will never learn[/b]. If all you do is push them down, they'll never look up.

 

Yeah... Smart.

 

 

I actually disagree... If someone comes up ad says "Your lighting is messed" it'll mean he'll just have to improve it by trying different methods and posting more tags. this is how someone improves. Not by making 2000 versions of the same artwork.

[Guest JoshIcy]

ITT: Giving someone criticism means you need to be an twat and an a$$ to get the point across.

 

Since when? If all you are' date=' is mean to the person they will never improve. [b']If all you do is point out the faults they will never learn[/b]. If all you do is push them down, they'll never look up.

 

Yeah... Smart.

 

 

I actually disagree... If someone comes up ad says "Your lighting is messed" it'll mean he'll just have to improve it by trying different methods and posting more tags. this is how someone improves. Not by making 2000 versions of the same artwork.

 

 

See... Thats diluted. It's neutral. Whatever...

 

The comments I was pointed at are the one who spike it with poison, which does NOTHING. While sugar coating does better at least, by telling them to do more and hopefully overtime they can improve. Beating someone does just that, beat them down. Nothing gained, only lost.

[metalflygon08]

I'm more for the Pointing out the flaw, but following up with the way they can IMPROVE it

 

ex"it's ok metalflygon09, but the lightsource varies in several spots, I'd try to move it to 1 central location, and adjust the shading as such."

 

unless the person really sucks and prances about stealing work/saying their the best.

[chairman ali]

ITT: Giving someone criticism means you need to be an twat and an a$$ to get the point across.

 

Since when? If all you are' date=' is mean to the person they will never improve. [b']If all you do is point out the faults they will never learn[/b]. If all you do is push them down, they'll never look up.

 

Yeah... Smart.

 

I actually disagree... If someone comes up ad says "Your lighting is messed" it'll mean he'll just have to improve it by trying different methods and posting more tags. this is how someone improves. Not by making 2000 versions of the same artwork.

 

See... Thats diluted. It's neutral. Whatever...

 

The comments I was pointed at are the one who spike it with poison, which does NOTHING. While sugar coating does better at least, by telling them to do more and hopefully overtime they can improve. Beating someone does just that, beat them down. Nothing gained, only lost.

 

Then again, this rarely happens. It only happens when the person doesn't like the poster tbh. They start by saying that it is fail and terrible and just point the crap in it in a harsh way. I got lots of attacks in this thread because they don't really like me :\ (I don't really give a damn about it).

[Guest JoshIcy]

ITT: Giving someone criticism means you need to be an twat and an a$$ to get the point across.

 

Since when? If all you are' date=' is mean to the person they will never improve. [b']If all you do is point out the faults they will never learn[/b]. If all you do is push them down, they'll never look up.

 

Yeah... Smart.

 

I actually disagree... If someone comes up ad says "Your lighting is messed" it'll mean he'll just have to improve it by trying different methods and posting more tags. this is how someone improves. Not by making 2000 versions of the same artwork.

 

See... Thats diluted. It's neutral. Whatever...

 

The comments I was pointed at are the one who spike it with poison, which does NOTHING. While sugar coating does better at least, by telling them to do more and hopefully overtime they can improve. Beating someone does just that, beat them down. Nothing gained, only lost.

 

Then again, this rarely happens. It only happens when the person doesn't like the poster tbh. They start by saying that it is fail and terrible and just point the crap in it in a harsh way. I got lots of attacks in this thread because they don't really like me :\ (I don't really give a damn about it).

 

Then you need to see the difference on this site. The comments by people who "think they know what they're doing" (not the sugar baby ones) are downright prickish. Even if they know what they're doing, their comments don't help anyone.

[metalflygon08]

O RLY?

 

 

it may be becuase I don't do C&C outside of sprites, but usually I don't see too many pricks, until the OP of a thread overeacts to a crit that they viewed as harsh.(though to be honest most crit on somthing you put your time and honest effort into cuts deeper than intended)

[Guest]

1. Im the master flamer I once porn bombed the mod forums so I auto win there >.>

2. Stop the bloody flaming or I will get this damn thread locked >.>

3. Ken was kidding, we are on the same art team lol

[Scyire]

Why do people even care what other people say about your GFX? I always look out for that one person who strides away from the,

"THIS SUCKS jabroni!" or,

"Good text, good blending", and find the one person who can actually give me advice on how to improve said gfx, and me as a gfx-er overall.

You can't moderate what people are going to say about what you do because everyone has different opinions. You just search for people who take it seriously, and work from there.

[JG.]

Icy, give up teh arguement. You will lose.

[~Energy]

Okay look when we come to you giving you criticism' date=' advice and even motivation images you accept it an move on. NO ONE SHOULD argue with a poster except the OP. Because seriously, most of you fail at come backs and arguments. We give constructive criticism to:

A) Help you gain knowledge

B) Help you improve

C) Help you edit your stuff and make it better

D) Learn from the criticism to criticize other people.

 

We're not doing this because we're better and s***. If you don't want to accept that criticism PM the f***ing member to remove it. I mean I would be happy to remove it if you don't want it but I won't be the one that's losing.

 

Oh and any posts that are f***ed up I'll ask a mod to remove them 'cause if you can't have a mature discussion here then you'll never have one.

 

Discuss.

[/quote']

 

Some people really need to take this in.

[mrfrosty]

It's funny how a single post that features information regaurding the inportance of taking proper criticism in a mature manner turns into a trollfest :}.

 

Besides in constant searing and flaming, I think this thred could be inportand! Then when someone N00B happens that can't take it right, you politley direct them here. Personaly, I think that your language is a bit..... imposive chaster, but i see that you do good and mean good for this forum and the newest members here (correct me if i'm wrong)

 

I agree with this