Aqua Vs Link

[Aqua Girl]

Rules:

● Make a card that special Summons from the Deck.

● You must give a valid reason for your vote.

● First to 6 votes wins.

● Loser must give the winner 2 + reps.

● Do NOT vote on overused pics, bad GFX effects, effect length, or other stupid not really mattering reasons.

● If there are OCG problems State them Dont say "Your Card has beter OCG so I chose you."

 

 

When this card attacks a monster your opponent controls, you can Special Summon 1 level 3 or lower EARTH Monster from your Deck. During your End Phase, you can return the Special Summoned monster to your Deck to return 1 monster your opponent controls to its respective owner's hand.

 

 

Once per turn you can Tribute a monster(s) on your side of the field to Special Summon 1 monster from your Deck who's level is equal to the Tribued monster(s) Level.

[Deustodo]

I vote for Link, his card has a better OCG, and also its more useful than Aqua's Effect.

[Sploda]

I vote for Darklink because

1. It does more than just Special Summon which is useful

2. you can slowly elminate your opponent's cards 2 at a time

3. An awesome Pic that I need to copy.

 

Also rule #5 is wrong.

Picture, GFX, and the like aren't stupid they are parts of the card and therefore must be taken into consideration.

[Nexev]

I vote for Rushing Goblin, it's a bit culty as in not super splashable but works really well in places were it works.

 

I don't know why but I like cards that can only be used in certain decks but work well when they do.

 

And I have no idea who is who.

[Aqua Girl]

Creator..... I stole the ruels from Gefhx and edited..... I actualy agrr with you....

 

2-0 Link

[Shadow Zero]

Golden Summoner has a less restricted use of effect and is able to help more quickly bring out powerful monsters. for example, Marauding Captain Normal Summon then Special Summon Golden Summoner with Marauding Captains effect and Tribute them both for a Level 7 monster. anyway you toss it, that card is better.

 

I vote for whoever made the Golden Summoner card.

[Sploda]

@Zero

If Golden Summoner is used for tribute the effect doesn't take effect.

[Shadow Zero]

it does not say that. insofar as it does not specify, it can used as a part of its effect.

[Sploda]

If the card says "Once per turn" the card must be in play and is unaffeted by the effect unless otherwised stated.

I lost a tourney because of that very vague rule.

I was pissed.

[Aqua Girl]

Uhh

2-1 Link

[DL]

3-1 me, actually, Deus, Creator, and Nexev voted for me.

[Aqua Girl]

No deus dident give a reson, I said If you camplane about the ocg you have to tell.

[Shadow Zero]

you know, i had trouble with that during the Agni Kai as well. that reminds me, i have a whole long line of 1v1s waiting to be tended to. xD 7 of them against whamo-kun, a best of 3 against striker, another one against creator......*sighs and mumbles something about being terribly busy when he gets back on later.

[Darj]

I vote for "Golden Summoner" for the next reasons:

 

-Can fit in Chaos Decks.

-Decent ATK.

-It can Tribute herself along another monster to bring a high-level monster (Yes, it can Tribute herself. Is she couldn't, the effect would say "except this card" or "another monster(s) you control").

-Can exchange useless monster with others that may be helpful at that Time.

-You can disregard this but: It has a nice image.

 

It has OCG errors:

"on your side of the field" --> "you control"

"who's" --> "whose"

 

By the way, the clothes of "Golden Summoner" resembles to the armors and robes of "Lightsworns". Could I get the source of the image? I might want to make a Lightsworn version of her.

[DL]

so 2-2.

 

VOte peoplez.

[Aqua Girl]

Heres the Image I had to upload it but it wasn't that hard.

[Ikatsui]

Darklink

His effect is more useful, and I can see myself using this in my Deck

[Aqua Girl]

How is it more useful Give a reson, Read the ruels.

[DL]

actually, the rules don't say it has to say HOW it's useful. It just says give valid reason.

 

A card being more useful then another IS valid.

 

(I'm saying this solely because this contest will never finish otherwise...)

[Aqua Girl]

I vote for Darklink because

1. It does more than just Special Summon which is useful

2. you can slowly elminate your opponent's cards 2 at a time

3. An awesome Pic that I need to copy.

 

Also rule #5 is wrong.

Picture' date=' GFX, and the like aren't stupid they are parts of the card and therefore must be taken into consideration.

[/quote']

 

Is it hard to do this?

[DL]

nope, but it's not against the rules not to, hmmm? :/

 

I just don't want this contest to take frikin forever...

 

even if you were to get a vote like that, Id count it...

[El Make]

My vote, seeing as I have no idea who made which, goes to Rushing Goblin. It can help you get more monsters on the field while eliminating your opponent's next Normal Summon. The other card kind of wastes a Normal Summon unless you have a situation where you need a certain card. Oh, just looked at the card again and realized it was made by DL.... vote to DL!

[Guest Neo Fusion]

i dnt knw whose is which, so I pick rushing goblin

the effect just seems more thought out and less OPed than the other one, not that the other one is way OPed, only a little

[DL]

So it's either 5-2 or 4-2

 

I'll leave it up to aqua to decide...

[Sora]

When this card attacks a monster your opponent controls, you can Special Summon 1 level 3 or lower EARTH Monster from your Deck. During your End Phase, you can return the Special Summoned monster to your Deck to return 1 monster your opponent controls to its respective owner's hand.

 

Monster = monster.

Thats about it lol. Effect is nice and fits the card fine, but I was wondering, say you did attack and Special Summoned a monster, does that mean the monster can attack at that point since its during the Battle Phase?

 

Once per turn you can Tribute a monster(s) on your side of the field to Special Summon 1 monster from your Deck who's level is equal to the Tribued monster(s) Level.

 

Side of the field = You control. Its alot easier that way.

Who's = whose.

Tribued = Tributed.

Place a comma between Once per turn and you I think. I usually do that.

Effect is eh. Considering it has 1800 ATK, thats pretty op'd too. Theres no drawback except Tributing. Then again, you get a monster of the same Level that you get to choose.

 

Darklink gets my vote.