Rule suggestion for Realistic.

[Eury]

Realistic and Written are the only sections in CC I hang out in and Written is fine so...this can apply to all of CC or just Realistic.

 

I was thinking. Realistic needs a rule that states, "if you're not posting something helpful or constructive, don't post at all."

 

I've seen a lot of posts lately stating stuff like "good card 8/10!" or "i dont like it 5/10" or even just "7/10".

 

It's really annoying. So, just post what you guys think.

[Scyire]

I agree.

 

Often times I see a good user post a great review first, and then see six people follow up with saying the exact same thing condensed to a few words.

[Guest JoshIcy]

Expect it from newbies and post it to newbies. Find that balance.

Senior Members are expected to give more detailed responses. Same mechanic in Intros, has been applied there to keep new users active and cheerful.

 

But due to this expectation, it cannot be enforced without segregation which we will not have.

[Chimayou]

I just thinks its hilarious that Eurynome wants "helpful" and "constructive" post right after he made a totally unhelpful and unconstructive post like this:

 

Eurynome wrote:

"RE: [Discussion] Play custom cards on Kcvds

KCVDS sucks...and did anyone else notice the advertising going on in this thread?"

 

But yes i think we need to do more against meeningless posts or we should give them a place to be where they can spam each other the whole day. Sure some Mods cant read every post so we cant expect that spamming will never be seen in any forum. It doesnt matter where you are there are allways people spamming and if you look at the age group playing yugioh you will notice that its hard to get constructive posts with that topic.

 

I think the Mods know what they are doing so we cant do much more.

[Scyire]

I just thinks its hilarious that Eurynome wants "helpful" and "constructive" post right after he made a totally unhelpful and unconstructive post like this:

 

Eurynome wrote:

"RE: [Discussion] Play custom cards on Kcvds

KCVDS sucks...and did anyone else notice the advertising going on in this thread?"

 

But yes i think we need to do more against meeningless posts or we should give them a place to be where they can spam each other the whole day. Sure some Mods cant read every post so we cant expect that spamming will never be seen in any forum. It doesnt matter where you are there are allways people spamming and if you look at the age group playing yugioh you will notice that its hard to get constructive posts with that topic.

 

I think the Mods know what they are doing so we cant do much more.

 

He was completely right, it looked like you were advertising.

 

If you're trying to make a point, don't start it with that statement.

 

I respect Eurynome, and believe he is one of the most polite people on YCM.

[Chimayou]

For me it felt like an attack directed to myself.. And the post was neither helpful nor constructive.. If he wants to say something like that he could have just send a pm.

[Brushfire]

^ Pointing out flaws doesn't necessary have to be PM'd, especially if they're pointing out your mistakes to everyone else.

[Alexis Rhodes]

I aggre i learnt my lesson from a neg lol

[Admiral Tim]

what i hate is all the cards the noobs post. Most of them are crap and they spam up the forum.

[Kotaro]

what i hate is all the cards the noobs post. Most of them are crap and they spam up the forum.

Well they are new, you cant expect them to come on and make a great set out of nothing. Everyone, well most people would have started of making not so good cards.

 

It does get annoying, but I think 1 and 2 star members shouldnt have this rule, others should.

[Admiral Tim]

but still if you look in the pop culture forum you can barely find a good card in there.

[Dream]

I support.

[~Wright~]

I support, and completely agree. :)

[Phantom Roxas]

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/thread-179578.html

 

Although, I do support this.

[Lolimar]

I totally support, look at these comments I've gotten for example.

 

8/10 very good considering ur new

 

9/10.

 

interesting :)

 

Awesome' date=' 9/10

[/quote']

 

(DEP) Oh' date=' okay.

[/quote']

[Guest JoshIcy]

Expect it from newbies and post it to newbies. Find that balance.

Senior Members are expected to give more detailed responses. Same mechanic in Intros' date=' has been applied there to keep new users active and cheerful.

 

But due to this expectation, it cannot be enforced without segregation which we will not have.

[/quote']

[~ P O L A R I S ~]

Expect it from newbies and post it to newbies. Find that balance.

Senior Members are expected to give more detailed responses. Same mechanic in Intros' date=' has been applied there to keep new users active and cheerful.

 

But due to this expectation, it cannot be enforced without segregation which we will not have.

[/quote']

 

"Segregation"? Really?

[Legendary Voltaic]

Icy's right. Can you encourage them to do it somehow?

[General Assclown]

After posting your thread, just post in it somewhere "Any Non-Detailed Ratings will be reported as I see them as spam" or something. I used to do it so why not you?

[KindredTether]

I think it's a good idea but this is expected for newbies.