Jump to content

challenge creation

Leturn Master

By Leturn Master
in Finished Contests

Do you prefer this kind of contest over others? (if so, let's make more!)  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Do you prefer this kind of contest over others? (if so, let's make more!)

    • Yeah, this style is cooler than the kind with rankings
      9
    • no, i like the first style.. stop wasting my time.
      1

Recommended Posts

Leturn Master Newbie

Leturn Master

Posted
Posted

I love the idea behind this game. The challenge here is not to find out who's the best, but to find out how good you are at creating cards. Rules are as follow:

1. After you tell me that you are ready (either via PM or post. PM is best because ill most likely get back to you sooner) i will give you a random set of card requirements. (Any three among: ATK, DEF, Attribute, Type, part of effect, rarity, card name, card style, card trend, and just about anything else aside from the picture) and you will have to create a card based around the set requirements. Trust me, i will remember them

2. "Winners" are decided through grading based on the following:

  • Are the requirements fulfilled? (can't put it in if the requirements aren't met)
  • Is it original? (3/3)
  • Is the picture good? (2/2) 8D And...
  • Is the card balanced? (3/3)
  • Is it useful? (2/2)

and then i take all your Points and put them over 10!

A "winner" is decided if someone gets above a 8.5/10 (that'll be quite hard. i shall make it so!)8)

3. "Winners" receive rewards based on their scorings:

  1. 8.5-8.9: 5 Points
  2. 9-9.4: 1 Rep
  3. 9.5-9.9: 1 Rep and 10 Points
  4. 10: 2 Reps and 10 points :shock:

i hope this is a challenge to all of you! ('specially god kaze & instinctmeister):D

 

CONTEST ENDS NOVEMBER 30TH, SO BE QUICK!!!)

 

wow, i love smilies...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Leturn Master Newbie

Leturn Master

Posted
  • Author
Posted

hey! im doubling points cause i got 50 from a very kind recipient (he can mention himself if he pleases)any way...

instincmeister created a card called Light Blade:

Profile: “Instinctmeister”

 

Card: “Light Blade”

Originality – 2.6/3.0 Reason: I’ve seen cards similar in effect (such as the effect to not be targeted by traps, or that when a monster is destroyed, you draw a card.) However, there aren’t a lot, so it’s in good shape.

Picture Quality – 1.8/2.0 Reason: The focal points of the picture are confusing. One of them is the knight, the other is the horse hooves, and the third is the spear. If the card is called light blade, the spear should take up more space than the knight torso or the horse legs. Still, it’s not pixilated and it has the full body of the character in it, so it makes most of the points.

Balance – 2.5/3.0 Reason: (This one’s long and boring, you might wanna skip it over. But if you don’t, read on :))

The first part of the card says: “When this card attacks, you may discard a card from your hand to activate one of the following effects:” It does not specify how many times you may activate this effect; If I had 5 cards in my hand and discarded them all to activate the third part of the effect, if I destroyed a monster I would get to draw 5 cards, since the effect is coming into play 5 times.

The first bullet point is good for a card effect. I have no qualms (I love that word!) with this idea

Next, the second bullet point states that the card will gain a resistance to battle damage. Problem is, how long? Since you didn’t specify, someone could take that as that you couldn’t take battle damage at any time after attacking, including the turn after you attacked, and the turn after, and the one after, etc. That would take a few points off, but I’m pretty sure you didn’t mean it that way... I hope. Regardless, this portion of the effect wouldn’t be very helpful because most people only would attack if they planned to destroy a monster. If they’re attacking a face-down monster or a monster in defense position, then their monster will be safe from destruction. I don’t see how this effect helps the card. It more seems to throw the effect off-balance.

The third bullet is good. The only flaw is the ability to take advantage multiple times using the pre-bulleted effect (think if I had infinite cards in my hand...) I didn’t take points off from here because I already have mentioned this.

The ATK of this card is well-balanced with the DEF. I would only suggest making the DEF a little lower, or making the card level one step higher, which would require an ATK and DEF increase.

Usefulness – 1.7/1.0 Reason: This card does seem useful at first, I must admit. However the problem is that, under speculation, the effect of this card combined with its other stats makes it a less-helpful card among others. The first effect of this card makes it an excellent solo fighter when combines with its attack. However discarding a card is a bit too much for this effect seeing as 4-star monsters aren’t normally selected as solo fighters in strategic duels. Along with that, the second bullet completely undermines the first, making this monster a defensive card as opposed to an offensive card, which the first bullet implies. The third bullet fits in with either the first one or the second. As a matter of fact, it fits in with any card. I like the ATK and DEF of this card, as well as making it low-level so it can hold its own while a player can compile stronger monsters In their hand for a tribute summon. The only thing I would want changed is either the first of the second bullet points, making it more defensive or offensive (respectively).

 

Overall Score: 1.7+2.5+1.8+2.6= 8.6/10

Hint: Fix the second bullet point!

Prize: 10 Points

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...