Duel-Off-Contest (FINISHED)

[Kizzi]

Right, this is my 2nd contest, and it is all about this card:

You must have 2 cards (not overpowered, at least 1 must be made with the card maker, you may use 1 existing), that can destroy this card or win the duel before your opponent's End Phase. Forbidden Emperor - Chaos Devourer is the only card on your opponent's side of the field. Your opponent has no cards in their hand, and has 4000 life points. You have 4000 life points.

Here's the rules:

2 cards

If you are using a pre-existing card you must post that as well

No overpowering

Good pictures

Good grammar

Must explain how your 2 cards can destroy FE-CD and/or win.

Hopefully ends 20th November if there are at least 3 entries.

1st place: 4 reps and 10 points.

2nd place: 2 reps

 

Entrants:

balvarine

bluetresure [cards posted]

uzumakinaruto93 (sorry if I spelt your name wrong) [X]

Chidori [cards posted]

Da-clown-of-hell [X]

cheeselord [cards posted]

Ixigo [cards posted]

 

Ranks:

1st: cheeselord (4 reps & 10 points)

2nd: bluetresure (2 reps, but I sent you a couple of points extra)

[Balvarine]

entry reserved!

[bluetresure]

entry reseverd

[uzumakinaruto93]

entry reserved

[Chidori]

entry reserved

[Cyber Altair]

entry reserved.

[bluetresure]

ok here are my entries

 

first use the monsters ability to inflict 2500 damage then sacrifice 3000 LP to do the last 1500 damage!

[Chidori]

and coming up after are mine:

use the monsters abillity to negate FE-CD ability then just use lightning vortex:P

[Tekken Ham]

i got this!

As long as this card is face-up on the Field your opponent cannot draw cards except during their draw phase. (Text might be too small cuz the pic was rly small.

ok summon Protector of the Sanctuary and use Exaustion, pay 2000 Life Points and FE-CD dies! XD

[Kizzi]

Could you post Protector of the Sanctuary plz?

EDIT: Never mind, I got it here.

[bluetresure]

bump

[mohdjum]

 

with brain control i take control of the Forbidden Emperor - Chaos Devourer and my life points drop to 3200 then i use the megamorph to double its attack points and attack my opponent directly with the 6000 atk points to win

[bluetresure]

he can just negate braincontroll, read the card and at least 1 of the cards must be made using the card maker

[Kizzi]

he can just negate braincontroll' date=' read the card and at least 1 of the cards must be made using the card maker

[/quote']

Yep. You read the rules very well.

[bluetresure]

well i like this contest, and i spent like 40min start on those cards and I usualy dont have the patience

 

edit: the pic for the secound one took the longest, that wasnt the image i wanted to use but it looked better

and the other one didnt work.

[Kizzi]

This contest has more entries than I expected! Maybe my card isn't so "perfect" after all xD.

[Guest Ixigo]

Your wording makes me assume the effect of Forbidden Emperor is compulsory for the user, so I designed this pair:

 

 

 

Activate Destiny Dominus, then equip Remnants of the Sanctuary to the Forbidden Emperor, forcing the enemy to draw a card and pay 500 life points. Then, retrieve the card and repeat the process until the opponent runs out of life points or cards.

[bluetresure]

FLAW!!!! it donst say he has to negate the effect

[Razieus]

I'm not sure. I think Ixigo's effect might actually work, since it doesn't say "When this card is involved with a card effect, you MAY draw 1 card and show it to the opponent to negate that card effect." It doesn't seem optional to me.

 

Anyways, I'm thinking of my own way to defeat this card. Nice card art BTW.

[bluetresure]

i think the card is good but unless it says u "must" then its ure choise to use or not

[Kizzi]

Ixigo, could you please clarify, I'm not sure I understand how you win.

[bluetresure]

could you answere this question for us? do you HAVE to use the effect?

[Razieus]

i think the card is good but unless it says u "must" then its ure choise to use or not

 

The card's good, but I'm thinking the effect is mandatory. I think this is similar to Pot of Avarice-Pot of Avarice doesn't say "You must have 5 monsters in the Graveyard to activate this card. Select 5 Monster Cards from your Graveyard, then add them to your Deck and shuffle it. After that, draw 2 cards." It just says "Select 5 Monster Cards from your Graveyard, then add them to your Deck and shuffle it. After that, draw 2 cards." I think that if it was optional, it would say "you MAY".

...................................

I just realized Ixigo doesn't win. "Forbidden Emperor-Chaos Devourer" only NEGATES the effect, not DESTROYS it. If it destoryed it, it would say "Negate that card effect and destroy the card" or something along those lines. So it wouldn't be destroyed. Ixigo meant that "Remnants of the Sanctuary" IMMEDIATLY returns to the hand, not at the End Phase or Standby Phase. So he could keep equipping it and you would keep drawing cards and losing 500 Life Points-that is, if the effect was mandatory. If it was optional, then the card could stay equipped...

..........

Wait. He couldn't win anyway. "Destiny Dominus" would be negated-it's involved with the negation effect-in this case, drawing a card-and would be negated. So both card effects would be negated, both cards would remain on the field(remember, "Remnants of the Sanctuary" isn't negated AND destroyed-it's just negated. It's still equipped except the effect is negated), but the other player would draw 2 cards.

 

I edited my post quite a few times after I realized a few things.

[bluetresure]

No offence but i would like an answere from the card creator.

and pot of avarice dose say "select 5" so you have to have 5 monsters in your graveyard to use it, u might think this is quouting u but its not. think about it.

[Razieus]

No offence but i would like an answere from the card creator.

and pot of avarice dose say "select 5" so you have to have 5 monsters in your graveyard to use it' date=' u might think this is quouting u but its not. think about it.

[/quote']

 

Oh no. I wasn't trying to answer the question for you-I was just giving you my opinion. And I know it says "select 5" but it doesn't say "You MUST have 5 monsters". So I kinda had the idea that "Forbidden Emperor" is mandatory in the same way. Lemme put it this way:

Pot of Avarice could say two things:

-You may select UP to five monsters in your Graveyard(which means you don't have to have 5) OR

-Select 5 monsters in your Graveyard(which means you must have 5).

Forbidden Emperor-Chaos Devourer could say two things:

-When this card is involved with a card effect, you may draw 1 card and show it to the opponent to negate that card effect.(Which isn't what it says)

-When this card is involved with a card effect, you draw 1 card and show it to the opponent to negate that card effect."

 

The way I take it, Forbidden Emperor's effect is TELLING you to draw one card, not ASKING you if you want to or not.

 

But, I want a ruling from the card's creator. Also, this arguing is kinda pointless, since Ixigo can't win anyway, as I've already explained in my previous post-although I edited it, since I thought he could win but then realized he couldn't.